decorative
Get A
Free
Estimate
Today

Blog

Snow and long icicles accumulating along a residential roof, gutters, and eaves during winter.

Full-Coverage Ice and Water Shield: Pros and Cons

With winter coming, are you concerned that ice dams will do some damage to your roof? You may have overheard roofers putting in a good word for “full-coverage ice and water shield” and been left to wonder if the price tag is justified. Is it an upgrade a Maine home can do without?

We get those questions and we are not alone in them. Home Roofing Solutions has 25 years of experience under our belt when it comes to shielding Maine roofs from what is some of the harshest winter weather in the nation. Put down the phone and give us a ring at (207) 489-2904 to discuss the particulars of your roof. Until then, we offer an unvarnished view of full-coverage ice and water shield and the trade offs involved.

What Is Ice and Water Shield?

It is a self-adhering membrane applied to the roof deck prior to the shingles. The membrane puts a waterproof barrier in place by sealing around nails so no water makes its way into the house.

Normally one will see this put in only where a leak is most probable: the eaves, the valleys and any penetrations. Full-coverage takes the membrane and wraps the whole roof deck, not just the problem areas.

The difference between the two is plain to see:

  • A standard application is limited to eaves, valleys and the area around chimneys, vents and skylights
  • Full-coverage goes from eave to ridge
  • With standard, the open field of the roof is left to the shingles and underlayment for protection
  • Full-coverage puts a second layer of waterproofing under it all
  • It is more expensive given the material and labor required

The Pros of Full-Coverage

Maine is a state where there is ample reason to think about full coverage. Between the long winters and the freeze-thaw cycles, a roof is under a good deal of stress.

The advantages are:

  • More robust defence against ice dams that form as snow refreezes at the eaves and drives water up under the shingles
  • If high wind gets to the shingles, you have a backup
  • Low-slope sections where water is slow to drain are better protected
  • For a roof with a lot of valleys and complications, it provides some peace of mind
  • Coastal and island homes get better performance in the face of salt air and driving rain

For our customers out in the mountains near Farmington and Greenville or along the coast where the snow load is heavy, it is a sound investment.

The Cons of Full-Coverage

We like to be upfront and full-coverage is not the answer for every job.

There are some downsides:

  • The cost is higher to begin with on account of the extra time and material
  • Certain roof systems require adequate attic airflow and ventilation to function with a sealed deck
  • Good insulation in the attic is the true remedy for ice dams; this is no replacement for it
  • In milder climes on a simple roof, the protection is superfluous

Full coverage is a solid option but it should be part of a well put together system, not a quick fix. We have seen homeowners shell out for the upgrade yet still have problems because they did not put the same care into their insulation and ventilation.

How to Decide What Is Right for You

Your budget, your location in Maine, the slope of the roof and the attic configuration will dictate the right course of action. A steeply pitched and well ventilated roof in Portland is not the same as a cottage on one of the coastal islands.

This is what we do for a living. As a family and veteran run firm we put the same stock in your roof as we would our own. We are Fortify Maine Certified and hold a Platinum-level manufacturer certification, and we take part in the Fortify Maine Homes program for FORTIFIED Home roof work. Our Solution Guarantee collection vouches for our product and workmanship, with the 50-year Platinum Lifetime Solution Guarantee being the top of the line. On top of that we have a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

Call Home Roofing Solutions at (207) 489-2904 for a straight talk on whether full-coverage is worth it for your home. We are here from 7:00am to 9:00pm to provide a free estimate and can arrange financing through a number of lenders come what may of your credit history. Get in touch and let us see to it that your home is in good shape for the next few Maine winters.

Don’t delay. call today!

Get a free roofing estimate from Home Roofing Solutions